If you’ve been injured in a car accident in Washington, you may assume that once insurance pays your medical bills, that part of the process is over. Unfortunately, that’s often not the case. Many injured people are surprised to learn—sometimes at the end of their case—that insurance companies may demand repayment through a process called subrogation.
That is why it is important to NOT settle your case too early. Insurance companies want to stop paying and want to limit their costs. Understanding subrogation is critical, because it can directly affect how much compensation you actually take home after a settlement or verdict.
At Althauser Rayan Abbarno, we regularly help injured clients navigate their personal injury cases after an accident and resolve subrogation claims to protect your financial recovery.
What Is Subrogation?
Subrogation is the legal right of an insurance company to seek reimbursement for money it paid on your behalf after an accident that was caused by someone else.
In simple terms:
- Your insurer pays your medical bills or lost wages
- You later recover money from the at-fault driver
- The insurer may demand repayment from that recovery
Subrogation applies even though you paid premiums for the coverage.
Common Sources of Subrogation in Washington Injury Claims
Several entities may assert subrogation or reimbursement rights after a car accident, including:
- Personal Injury Protection (PIP) insurers
- Health insurance companies
- Workers’ Compensation (L&I)
- Medicare
- Medicaid
- Medical providers with liens
Each type of claim is governed by different laws, and some are far more negotiable than others.
How Subrogation Works Step by Step
- Insurance Pays Bills
- Your PIP coverage or health insurance pays medical expenses
- Wage loss benefits may also be paid
- Injury Claim Is Made
- A claim is pursued against the at-fault driver’s insurance or through your UIM coverage
- Settlement or Verdict Occurs
- Compensation is obtained for medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering
- Subrogation Claims Are Asserted
- Insurers notify you or your attorney that they want reimbursement
- Claims Are Paid or Negotiated
- Subrogation must be resolved before settlement funds are distributed
Washington’s Made Whole Doctrine
Washington follows the Made Whole Doctrine, which is one of the most important protections for injured people.
What It Means
An insurance company generally cannot recover subrogation unless you have been fully compensated—or “made whole”—for all of your damages, including:
- Medical expenses
- Lost wages
- Future losses
- Pain and suffering
If the available insurance coverage is limited and does not fully compensate you, subrogation claims may be reduced or eliminated entirely.
Insurance companies often dispute whether someone has been “made whole,” which is why experienced legal representation matters.
PIP Subrogation in Washington
PIP coverage is commonly the first source of payment after a car accident.
Washington law limits PIP reimbursement:
- PIP insurers may only seek repayment after you are made whole
- Their recovery must be reduced by:
- Attorney’s fees
- Costs
- Your percentage of comparative fault
Improper handling of PIP reimbursement can significantly reduce an injured person’s net recovery.
Health Insurance Subrogation: ERISA vs. Non-ERISA Plans
Health insurance subrogation depends heavily on the type of policy involved.
ERISA (Employer-Sponsored) Plans
- Often have strong reimbursement language
- May override Washington’s Made Whole Doctrine
- Plan language controls, not state law
Non-ERISA or Individual Plans
- Usually subject to Washington’s Made Whole rule
- Often more negotiable
Determining whether a plan is governed by ERISA requires review of the full plan document—not just a summary.
Medicare and Medicaid Subrogation
Government programs operate under different rules:
- Medicare reimbursement is required by federal law
- Medicaid (Apple Health) also has mandatory reimbursement rights
- These claims must be reported and resolved properly
- Penalties can apply if reimbursement is mishandled
Although these claims usually cannot be eliminated, they are often subject to reduction.
Subrogation vs. Medical Liens
Subrogation is often confused with medical liens, but they are not the same.
- Subrogation: An insurer already paid bills and seeks reimbursement
- Medical lien: A provider treats you now and gets paid later from your settlement
Medical liens must typically be paid before settlement funds are distributed and can significantly reduce your net recovery if not carefully managed.
Common Mistakes That Cost Injury Victims Money
- Settling a claim before subrogation is resolved
- Assuming insurers will not seek repayment
- Failing to assert the Made Whole Doctrine
- Signing medical lien agreements unnecessarily
- Giving recorded statements without legal advice
These mistakes can cost injured people thousands of dollars.
Why Subrogation Matters to Your Recovery
Subrogation often determines how much money you actually keep, not how much your case settles for.
Handled correctly, subrogation claims can often be reduced or eliminated. Handled incorrectly, they can consume a large portion of your settlement. Many experienced law firms like Althauser Rayan Abbarno work to secure the most compensation for your case and also work to resolve subrogation.
Talk to a Washington Personal Injury Attorney
If you were injured in a car accident and are dealing with medical bills, lost wages, or insurance reimbursement demands, legal guidance can make a significant difference.
The attorneys at Althauser Rayan Abbarno have extensive experience handling Washington car accident claims, PIP benefits, UIM coverage, medical liens, and subrogation disputes.
📞 Free consultations available
🌐 Visit www.CentraliaLaw.com
🗣️ Spanish-language interpretation available
Understanding subrogation early protects your rights—and your recovery.
Recent Comments